Paid Newsletter Recommendations vs Ads: The Math
beehiiv Boosts, SparkLoop and Kit pay per subscriber; ads pay per open. The fees, the screening rules and a formula for which earns you more.

Paid recommendations and ads pay a newsletter for two different things. Recommendations, through beehiiv Boosts, SparkLoop or Kit’s Creator Network, pay you a fixed amount, typically $1 to $4 or more, for each new subscriber you send to another newsletter who passes its checks, less a platform fee of around 20%. Ads pay you for the attention of the readers you already have, per open or per placement. So recommendations earn from your growth and ads earn from your size. With the assumptions in this post, a newsletter growing faster than about 2.5% a month earns more from recommendations than from one programmatic ad slot, and a larger, slower-growing list earns more from ads. Most publishers should run both, because they happen at different moments: one when someone subscribes, the other every time an issue is opened.
The comparisons that rank for this question are mostly written by the platforms that sell recommendations, or by creators with an affiliate link to them. They describe the upside well and skip the arithmetic. Below is the arithmetic, the fees and holds from each platform’s own documentation, and the trade-offs I would think about as a publisher. I build MailAdx, a newsletter ad exchange, so I have a side in this; I have tried to show the numbers in a way you can check against your own.
How paid recommendations work
When someone subscribes to your newsletter, the page they land on next can suggest other newsletters. If they tick one, their email is passed to that newsletter, which pays you for the subscriber if they turn out to be real and engaged. You are, in effect, an affiliate for other newsletters, paid on cost per acquisition (CPA).
Three networks dominate. Here is what their own documentation says about the terms that affect your income:
beehiiv Boosts SparkLoop Kit Creator Network
─────────────────── ──────────────────── ───────────────────── ─────────────────────
Platform fee 20%, built into the 20% commission plus 20% service fee plus
price you see a processing fee 3.5% transaction fee
Who can join beehiiv publications beehiiv, Kit, Sailthru Kit creators, via
and other "pro" ESPs SparkLoop
How a sub is judged Engagement, location Anti-fraud checks, Run by SparkLoop
and behaviour data no unsubscribe or
low-engagement removal
in the screening window
Screening window Not stated Usually 10-14 days Not stated
Payout Stripe Express Monthly Through SparkLoopSources: beehiiv’s Boosts FAQ, SparkLoop’s paid recommendations page and its help article on budgets, and Kit’s help article on paid recommendations. Kit bought SparkLoop in 2023, which is why Kit’s paid recommendations run on it.
Three details matter more than the headline price.
The fee is already inside the number you see on beehiiv. beehiiv’s example: a newsletter paying $2.50 per subscriber appears to you as a $2.00 offer. On SparkLoop and Kit the fee comes off your payout, so a $2.50 referral pays you a little under $2.00.
Not every referral gets paid. SparkLoop holds each referral for a screening window, usually 10 to 14 days. A subscriber who fails the fraud checks, unsubscribes, or is removed for not opening anything in the first 14 days is not paid. Referrals made after the buyer’s monthly budget runs out are not paid either, and the help article says no exceptions are made.
You do not choose every buyer by hand unless you want to. On beehiiv, some offers auto-accept your recommendation and some need the other publication’s approval. You can block or report a publication, and you should look at each one you recommend. Your reader’s first act after trusting you is to trust your suggestion.
Substack has recommendations too, but they are free. SparkLoop lists Substack, Ghost and SendFox among the platforms it does not support, so a Substack publisher has no paid route through these networks today.
How newsletter ads pay, for comparison
Ads pay for the readers you already have. There are three common arrangements:
- Direct sponsorships. You sell a placement to a brand for a flat fee or a CPM. Typically the highest rate, and the most work. The rate-setting guide and the sponsorship rate calculator cover pricing.
- An ad network or marketplace. A platform sells your slot to its advertisers and keeps a share. Less work, lower rate, and your income depends on how often the slot is filled.
- Programmatic. An ad decided at the moment of open, bought by whichever buyer pays most. The sponsorships versus programmatic post compares the two.
To keep the comparison concrete I will use MailAdx’s published default fees, because I know exactly how they work. When an advertiser on our network buys your slot at a $10 CPM, the buyer pays $10.00 per thousand impressions, a 15% buy-side fee leaves $8.50, a 15% sell-side share takes $1.275, and you are credited $7.225. The billing help article has the full table, including direct-sold, where you keep everything the sponsor pays you and pay a $0.40 CPM serving fee.
An impression on MailAdx is counted when the ad loads as the email is opened, because the ad is chosen at that moment rather than when the email is sent. The open-time ad serving explainer describes why. The practical effect is that ad income tracks real opens, not list size.
The formula: growth versus size
Here is the comparison reduced to two lines. Monthly income from recommendations:
Recommendations = S x p x v x c S new subscribers per month on your own signup forms p paid recommendations accepted per new subscriber v share of those referrals that pass screening and get paid c what you receive per paid referral, after the fee
Monthly income from one ad slot:
Ads = N x o x k x f x e / 1000 N subscribers o share who open each issue (measured honestly, see below) k issues per month f fill rate: share of opens where a paid ad was shown e what you receive per 1,000 impressions, after fees
Look at the first letter of each. Recommendation income is driven by S, new subscribers. Ad income is driven by N, total subscribers. A list that is growing fast relative to its size will earn more from the first. A big list that grows slowly will earn more from the second.
Two cautions on the inputs. Your open rate is almost certainly overstated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection, which loads images for many Apple Mail users whether or not they read the email; the post on Gmail and Apple MPP tracking explains how to discount it. And p, the number of recommendations a new subscriber accepts, varies so much with page design and audience that I have not found an independent benchmark I trust. Use your own figure after a month of running them.
Two worked examples
These numbers are assumptions chosen to be plausible and easy to follow, not benchmarks. Change them to yours.
Recommendations, the same for both newsletters: 2,000 new subscribers a month, 0.6 paid recommendations accepted per new subscriber, 70% of referrals paid, $2.00 received per paid referral.
2,000 x 0.6 x 0.7 x $2.00 = $1,680 a month
Ads, one slot per issue: 40% open rate, 12 issues a month, 60% fill, $7.225 received per 1,000 impressions.
Newsletter A Newsletter B
(10,000 subs) (100,000 subs)
───────────────────── ────────────────── ──────────────────
Monthly growth 2,000 (20%) 2,000 (2%)
Opens per month 48,000 480,000
Paid impressions 28,800 288,000
Ad income $208 $2,081
Recommendation income $1,680 $1,680For the small, fast-growing newsletter, recommendations earn eight times what the ad slot does. For the large one, the ad slot wins, and that is one slot at network rates. A single direct sponsor at a higher CPM, or a second slot, would widen the gap.
To see how wide, suppose Newsletter B sells one sponsor four issues a month at a $30 CPM, and fills the rest from the network. Four issues at 40,000 opens is 160,000 impressions. The sponsor pays B $4,800 directly, and on MailAdx the direct-sold serving fee on those impressions is $64, so B keeps $4,736 from one sponsor. Recommendations would have to grow almost threefold to match that, and they can only grow if signups do.
The small newsletter cannot sell that sponsor yet. At 4,000 opens an issue, the same $30 CPM is $120 a send, which is barely worth a sales conversation for either side. This is the real reason recommendations suit young newsletters: not that they pay well, but that they pay something before the audience is big enough to sell.
Set the two formulas equal and you get the growth rate at which they break even. With these assumptions it is about 2.5% a month: (0.4 x 12 x 0.6 x 0.007225) / (0.6 x 0.7 x 2.00) = 0.0248. Grow faster than that and recommendations earn more than one network-demand slot. Grow slower and the slot earns more. Your break-even will differ, and that is the point of working it out. The newsletter ad revenue calculator and the eCPM and fill rate calculator will give you the ad side from your own numbers.
Notice what is missing from both formulas: the reader. Recommendation income does not depend on whether your existing readers open your issues at all. Ad income does not depend on whether you are growing. A newsletter that is buying growth with paid acquisition and running recommendations can look profitable on recommendations while its open rate falls. That is worth watching.
They rarely compete for the same space
Recommendations are shown at signup. Ads appear inside issues. For most publishers that means the two do not fight over inventory, and the question is not “which one” but “how much of each”.
The exception used to be paid placements inside the issue itself. beehiiv ran Email Boosts, where one newsletter paid to be promoted in another’s send. Its FAQ now says Email Boosts are retired: no new ones can be created, and those already running continue until they expire. That leaves the issue for ads and the signup page for recommendations, which is a clean split.
There is one other place they meet: your welcome sequence. Some publishers put recommendations in the first automated emails as well as on the signup page. Those emails are also ad inventory, and often your best-opened. The post on the ad inventory your media kit does not count covers how to price them. If you use them for recommendations, count what an ad there would have earned as the cost.
When another newsletter wants to pay you per subscriber
A common offer, especially once you have some readers, is a newsletter asking for a placement in your issue and offering to pay per subscriber it gains. That is a CPA sponsorship. It moves all of the risk onto you: if their pitch is weak, you gave away the slot for nothing.
You can test an offer like this with one sum. Work out what the slot earns you on a CPM basis, then the subscribers they would need to match it:
Slot value at your floor: 20,000 opens x $15 CPM / 1000 = $300 Their offer: $2.00 per verified subscriber Break-even subscribers: $300 / $2.00 = 150 Needed subscribe rate: 150 / 20,000 opens = 0.75% of opens
If you do not believe 0.75% of your openers will subscribe to them and survive their checks, ask for a CPM or a flat fee, or a CPA with a minimum guarantee. The negotiation guide has scripts for this conversation, and the floor CPM guide explains how to set the number you compare against.
The costs that do not show up on a dashboard
Both models have costs that are real but hard to measure. They do not change the arithmetic above; they change how confident you should be in it.
Screening losses are yours. Referrals that fail verification, unsubscribe in the window, or arrive after the buyer’s budget is spent earn nothing. You still sent them. A low v is a sign that you are recommending newsletters your readers do not want, or that your signup page attracts low-intent subscribers in the first place.
The moment of signup is precious. A new subscriber has just decided to trust you. Recommending three other newsletters right then may make some of them less attached to yours. I know of no published study that measures this, so test it if your platform allows: show recommendations to some new subscribers and not others, and compare their open rates after 30 days.
Your recommendation is your reputation. A reader who ticks a newsletter you suggested and finds it low quality blames you a little. Approve each buyer, and turn off anything that auto-accepts if you would not put that newsletter in your own issue.
Payout friction. beehiiv needs Stripe identity verification and a Stripe Express account to pay you, and its FAQ says withdrawals can be paused while an account is under review. Earnings moved from recommendations into your own Grow budget cannot be reversed or withdrawn.
Deliverability runs one way for each. Recommending other newsletters does not touch your own sending: the subscribers you pass on are mailed by someone else. Buying subscribers does. If the people you pay for never open, your engagement falls and your spam complaints rise, and Google’s sender guidelines ask bulk senders to stay below a 0.1% spam rate and never reach 0.3%. Screening windows exist partly to protect buyers from this, which is why non-openers are rejected. Ads touch your sending in a different way: heavy images, link domains with a poor reputation, and emails long enough to be clipped by Gmail can all cost you inbox placement. The post on deliverability and ad revenue covers what to check.
A third offer will arrive. Once you have a list, someone will offer to rent it: send their email to your subscribers for a fee. It looks like easy money and is usually the worst of the three for your list. The post on list rental versus sponsorship runs the numbers.
Ads have their own hidden costs. A badly matched sponsor annoys readers, and too many ads push people to unsubscribe. The post on churn and ad revenue shows how to put a price on that, and ad fatigue covers what happens when the same sponsor runs too long.
If you are the one buying subscribers
Every recommendation has a buyer, and if you grow a newsletter you will probably be on that side too. On beehiiv, running an offer needs a $20 minimum deposit and funds of at least ten times your CPA, with one live offer at a time. You pay only for subscribers who pass verification.
The other way to buy subscribers is an ad in someone else’s newsletter. A sponsorship with a link to your signup page is the oldest version. A newer one is a subscribe button inside the email itself. On MailAdx this is the one-tap subscribe format in our interactive ads: a reader in Gmail, Yahoo Mail or AOL taps once, their address is passed to you with a consent record, and you send them your own confirmation email.
The cost per subscriber from an ad is the price of the impressions divided by the subscribers who confirm:
Cost per subscriber = CPM / (1000 x subscribe rate x confirm rate) Example, assumed rates: $10 / (1000 x 0.5% x 70%) = $2.86
The difference from a recommendation is who carries the risk. With CPA, the seller does; with CPM, the buyer does. Neither is free: a CPA buyer pays a premium for certainty, and a CPM buyer can do better or much worse than the example.
Why our subscribe ads are billed per impression
This section is about decisions we made building MailAdx, and the one number we do not have yet.
We charge per impression, never per subscriber. Everything on MailAdx is billed that way, including subscribe and lead forms. Taps, votes, leads and subscribers are reported as results and are never charged. We chose it because a newsletter is paid for the attention it delivers. Whether a buyer’s pitch converts is the buyer’s risk, not the publisher’s. It also makes the publisher’s income predictable, which a CPA arrangement never is.
Readers on Apple Mail see a static version, and it is charged. The interactive form only works in Gmail, Yahoo Mail and AOL, and only for sending addresses those providers have approved. Readers on Apple Mail and Outlook see a static fallback in the same place, which is a paid impression at the same CPM unless the buyer sets the line item to interactive only. A buyer who does not account for this will think their subscribe rate is lower than it really is in Gmail. Reports show static and interactive impressions separately for that reason; the fallback help article explains what each reader sees.
The reader always confirms by email. MailAdx does not send the confirmation. The consent sentence promises one, so the buyer must send their own before mailing. It costs some subscribers, and it keeps the buyer inside Gmail’s spam limits, which matter more than the subscribers lost.
The number we will not invent. I would like to tell you what share of impressions turn into confirmed subscribers on MailAdx. Our live volume is not yet large enough to publish one honestly, and a made-up benchmark is worse than none. When we have a figure based on real campaigns, it will go in this post with the date and the sample size.
A practical setup for a growing newsletter
If I were running a newsletter of a few thousand to a few tens of thousands of subscribers, this is how I would set it up.
- Turn recommendations on at signup with two or three newsletters you would happily recommend in an issue. Approve each one. Avoid auto-accept unless you have read the buyer.
- After 30 days, work out your own p and v from the dashboard. Now you have your real recommendation formula.
- Put one ad slot in each issue, at a floor that reflects what your audience is worth. Network or programmatic demand can fill it while you sell sponsors directly. The monetisation guide covers the order to do this in.
- Calculate your break-even growth rate with your own numbers. Above it, keep investing in growth and recommendations. Below it, put your effort into ad fill and direct sponsors.
- Watch open rates of new subscribers against older ones. If recommendations seem to weaken new readers’ attachment, show fewer.
For platform-specific setup, see the guides to adding ads alongside beehiiv and Kit, or the MailAdx and beehiiv Ad Network comparison if you are already on beehiiv and wondering about its built-in network.
The short version
Paid recommendations pay you for new subscribers you pass on. Ads pay you for the readers you keep. A fast-growing small newsletter can earn more from the first; a large, stable one almost always earns more from the second. They sit at different points in a reader’s life with you, so most publishers should run both and let their own numbers decide where the effort goes.
The publisher page explains how MailAdx fills ad slots, pricing lists the fees, and you can create an account to try it on your next issue.
Frequently asked questions
How much do paid newsletter recommendations pay?
Kit says creators pay between $1 and $4 or more per subscriber referred, and beehiiv and SparkLoop work in a similar range. A platform fee of around 20% comes off: beehiiv builds it into the price you see, while SparkLoop and Kit deduct it from your payout along with a processing fee. Only referrals that pass the buyer’s checks are paid.
Are beehiiv Boosts worth it?
For a newsletter that adds many new subscribers relative to its size, often yes, because the income comes from signups rather than opens. For a large list that grows slowly, ad slots usually earn more. Work out both with your own growth, open rate and fill rate before deciding, and approve each newsletter you recommend.
What is the difference between beehiiv Boosts and SparkLoop?
Both pay you per subscriber you refer. beehiiv Boosts only works for beehiiv publications and builds its 20% fee into the offer price. SparkLoop works across several email platforms, takes a 20% commission plus a processing fee from monthly payouts, and holds each referral for a screening window, usually 10 to 14 days. Kit’s paid recommendations run on SparkLoop.
Why was my paid recommendation not paid?
Usually because the subscriber failed the buyer’s checks: they failed fraud screening, unsubscribed during the screening window, or did not open anything in the first two weeks. On SparkLoop, a referral made after the buyer’s monthly budget ran out is not paid either.
Do paid recommendations hurt my newsletter?
They can if you recommend newsletters your readers do not value, because your reputation goes with the recommendation. Whether they weaken a new subscriber’s attachment to you is not well measured. If your platform allows it, show recommendations to some new subscribers and not others, and compare their open rates after a month.
Can I run ads and paid recommendations at the same time?
Yes, and most publishers should. Recommendations appear when someone subscribes; ads appear inside your issues. They only compete if you put recommendations inside issues or your welcome emails, in which case count what an ad in that space would have earned.
Stay ahead of the newsletter ad space
Get weekly articles on email monetisation, ad tech, and platform updates.
Subscribe + request demo →Editorial & Product
Related articles

Political Ads in Newsletters: A Publisher's Guide
What counts as a political ad, the US, EU, UK and India rules, why Gmail hiding location makes email harder, and a checklist before you say yes.

AMP for Email Ads: What Actually Works in Gmail
Interactive newsletter ads, tested in real Gmail inboxes: who can see them, the eleven formats, and the three layout rules that decide if an ad is seen.

ads.txt and sellers.json for Newsletter Ads
When a newsletter needs ads.txt and sellers.json, why Substack and beehiiv subdomains can't host one, and how we verify every publisher's line.
Ready to monetise your newsletter?
See how MailAdx fits your setup in a personalised 30-minute demo.